On This Page
Walmart+ costs $98 a year. Amazon Prime costs $139. That $41 gap is the entire pitch, and it’s a decent one — but the cheaper membership is only a better deal if it does the things you actually need. For a lot of people it doesn’t, and for a specific kind of household, it comprehensively does.
Here’s the honest accounting.
What Walmart+ Costs and Includes
$98/year, or $12.95/month. Paying monthly works out to $155.40 annually, so the yearly plan saves you about $57 — take the annual plan if you’re keeping it.
Also Read
BusinessIs Costco Executive Membership Worth It? The Math, Simplified→
What you get:
- Free delivery from Walmart stores, typically same-day, on qualifying orders
- Free shipping from Walmart with no order minimum
- A Paramount+ subscription (with ads) — genuinely worth something if you want CBS shows, Yellowstone, or Star Trek
- Fuel discounts at Walmart, Murphy USA, and participating stations
- Mobile scan & go in stores
The Head-to-Head with Amazon Prime
| Walmart+ | Amazon Prime | |
| Annual cost | $98 | $139 |
| Product selection | Limited to Walmart’s catalog | Vast marketplace |
| Grocery delivery | Core strength, same-day | Amazon Fresh, minimum order |
| Streaming included | Paramount+ (with ads) | Prime Video (with ads unless +$2.99/mo) |
| Fuel discounts | Yes | No |
| Free shipping minimum | None | None (Prime items) |
Amazon wins on breadth, decisively. Prime covers a marketplace with tens of millions of products from countless sellers. If you buy a wide variety of things online — electronics, books, obscure parts, niche brands — Walmart’s catalog will frustrate you, and no amount of savings fixes that.
Walmart wins on groceries and fuel. Same-day grocery delivery from a physical store you already shop at is a different product from Amazon Fresh, and for households doing a weekly grocery run it’s the stronger offering. Add fuel discounts if you drive, and the value stacks up fast.
Also ReadBusinessWall Street’s Next Billion-Dollar Shift Is Already Happening→
The same household budgeting logic applies to entertainment subscriptions. Someone comparing Spotify vs YouTube may value music, video content, or bundled services differently, just as Walmart+ and Prime appeal to different shopping habits.
The Break-even Math
At $98, Walmart+ needs to save you $98 a year to justify itself.
Grocery delivery alone can do it. Grocery delivery services typically charge $7–10 per order. If you use Walmart+ delivery just once a month, that’s roughly $84–120 in avoided fees—the membership pays for itself on that line item alone.
Fuel discounts help if you drive. The savings are modest per fill-up but compound across a year of commuting.
Paramount+ has real value if you’d otherwise pay for it—that’s roughly $60–80/year of streaming bundled in.
Stack grocery delivery and Paramount+, and the membership clears its own cost without you buying a single other thing.
Who should get Walmart+?
- Households that already shop at Walmart for groceries and household goods. This is the whole ballgame.
- Anyone who wants grocery delivery and lives near a Walmart store.
- Drivers who can use the fuel discount regularly.
- People who want Paramount+ anyway — the bundle makes the membership close to free.
- Anyone trying to cut costs who doesn’t need Amazon’s catalog breadth.
Who should skip it
- People who buy a wide range of products online. Walmart’s selection is the hard ceiling here, and it’s a real one.
- Anyone who doesn’t live near a Walmart. The store-delivery benefit—the best part—evaporates.
- Light shoppers. If you’re not placing regular orders, you won’t reach break-even on either membership.
- People who already have and use Prime heavily. Running both is rarely justified.
Should You Have Both?
Usually not, and the honest test is simple: what do you actually buy?
If your online spending is mostly groceries and household staples, Walmart+ covers it for $41 less. If it’s varied—gadgets, gifts, books, niche products—Prime’s marketplace is worth the premium, and Walmart+ adds little.
The one case for both: a large household that does heavy grocery delivery and buys widely online. That’s $237/year in memberships, so run the numbers on your actual order history before committing.
The same principle applies to other consumer expenses. Whether you’re budgeting for subscriptions, travel, or concert tickets, the headline price is only part of the calculation. Recurring fees, convenience charges, and add-ons can significantly change the final cost.
Understanding the Total Cost of Everyday Services
Membership comparisons can also highlight how difficult it has become to judge the true price of a service. A low advertised price may be followed by delivery charges, service fees, taxes, or other costs.
This is particularly noticeable when dining out or using service-based businesses. Knowing how tipping works can help consumers understand the difference between an advertised price and the amount they actually pay.
The Bottom line
Walmart+ is the better deal for a specific, common household: one that shops at Walmart, wants groceries delivered, drives a car, and doesn’t need a limitless online catalog. For that person, it’s cheaper than Amazon Prime and arguably more useful.
For everyone whose online life runs through Amazon’s marketplace, the $41 saving doesn’t survive contact with the selection gap. Cheaper isn’t better if it doesn’t stock what you buy.
Sources and References
Note: Prices and benefits change; confirm current terms directly with each service before subscribing. This is consumer analysis, not financial advice.
- Reviewed by editorial staff before publication.
- Fact-checking and source verification applied.
- Updated regularly for accuracy and clarity.
- Aligned with newsroom ethics and publishing standards.
Join the conversation