Chicago Went All-In on Jeffery Simmons. Here’s What the Bears Really Paid

On Thursday, October 29, 2026, the Tennessee Titans announced they were trading All-Pro defensive tackle Jeffery Simmons to the Chicago Bears. The deal came ahead of the NFL’s November 10 trade deadline (4 p.m. ET).

Terms per NFL, ESPN and Bleacher Report, all of which agree on the picks.

According to ESPN Research, this is the first time since the common draft era began in 1967 that a defensive tackle has been traded for multiple first-round picks.

Also ReadSportsA Four-Goal Finish Ends Barça’s Perfect Start: Inside PSG 4-2 Barcelona→

Why Would Tennessee Trade Its Best Player?

The short answer is that the Titans are 1-6, and the offer was too large to refuse.

Simmons wasn’t unhappy, and he wasn’t a locker-room problem. ESPN’s Turron Davenport reports that head coach Robert Saleh recently called him the best defensive tackle in the league. Titans defensive line coach Aaron Whitecotton held him up as the model for full-effort play. ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler adds that, from what people around the league are saying, Tennessee wasn’t actively shopping him. The Bears came in aggressively, and GM Mike Borgonzi got an offer he couldn’t turn down.

The timing made the move more jarring. Simmons told reporters on Wednesday that he hadn’t heard from his agent or the team, and said he expected to stay in Tennessee. A day later he was a Bear.

Also ReadSportsFootball Player Tyler Ulrich Dies After Severe Head Injury→

Bleacher Report’s Kristopher Knox gave Tennessee an A. His case rests on how the team has played since parting with Mike Vrabel after the 2023 season: only seven wins since the start of 2024. This year the Titans rank 32nd in total offense and 26th in total defense. Their lone win came against the Colts.

The most important variable is quarterback Cam Ward, the first overall pick in 2025. His passer rating has slipped from 80.2 as a rookie to 73.8 this season, even with new weapons around him. Two extra first-rounders give Borgonzi room to either build around Ward or pivot at the position.

ESPN’s draft analyst Jordan Reid notes that the Titans are currently projected by ESPN’s FootballPower Index to pick first in 2027. The incoming Bears pick is projected at No. 26. Reid names Ohio State receiver Jeremiah Smith as a realistic top target, and points to pass rusher and offensive tackle prospects as options if Tennessee trades down.

What Does Simmons Actually Bring To Chicago?

The Bears’ defense has a split personality. ESPN’s Courtney Cronin and Ben Solak point out that Chicago has the league’s best third-down defense, allowing conversions on 26.1% of attempts. But on early downs, it ranks 32nd in defensive EPA per play and 32nd in explosive plays allowed. Interior pass-rush win rate sits at 23rd, at 13%.

Simmons addresses that directly. NFL, citing Next Gen Stats, says he entered Week 8 with 28 pressures, the most among defensive tackles. That total includes 10 pressures and three sacks when double-teamed, both league-best for the position, along with 21 run stops, tied for second among DTs. ESPN’s version of the numbers differs slightly (it counts 25 pressures when he lines up at tackle, still tied for the most). The two outlets use different tracking definitions, but both put him at or near the top.

Last season he produced 11 sacks and 21 knockdowns in 15 games, earning first-team All-Pro honors for the first time. Since entering the league in 2019, his 46.5 sacks are second most among defensive tackles behind DeForest Buckner, per ESPN.

He joins a front that is getting Montez Sweat back from a two-game suspension and also includes veteran Grady Jarrett.

How Much Does Simmons Cost, and Who Absorbs The Cap Hit?

This is where the deal gets technical, and where the numbers from ESPN’s Dan Graziano are most useful.

For the Bears:

• The Bears take on the remaining $7,944,444 of his 2026 pay, which is also his 2026 cap charge.
• In 2027 he is owed $26.95 million (a $21.45 million salary plus a $5.5 million option bonus), all fully guaranteed. The Bears’ cap charge that year would be about $22.55 million.
• If he is still on the roster on the fifth day of the 2027 league year, $29.8 million of his 2028 pay becomes fully guaranteed.
• If he is still there on the fifth day of the 2028 league year, $10 million of his $28.001 million 2029 salary becomes guaranteed.

For the Titans:

• Simmons signed a three-year extension in June worth about $105.8 million with $100 million guaranteed (NFL figure; ESPN’s Bill Barnwell lists it as $105.9 million). Bleacher Report says it runs through 2030.
• Tennessee carries a 2026 cap charge of $14,116,398 and dead money of $21,210,843 in 2027.
• Bleacher Report notes the Titans lead the league in available cap space, so the dead money hurts less than it would for most teams.

Did The Bears Overpay? What The Critics Say

This is where the coverage splits, and it’s where the analysis gets interesting.

ESPN’s Barnwell is the most skeptical voice among the sources reviewed. He counts this as the 10th trade involving two first-round picks for a veteran player since the Bears acquired Khalil Mack in 2018, and he puts the success rate at roughly two wins in eight decided cases, with the Packers’ Micah Parsons deal still unresolved. His successes are the Rams’ trades for Jalen Ramsey and Matthew Stafford. His failures include Jamal Adams, Russell Wilson, Deshaun Watson and Sauce Gardner.

His other arguments:

• Age. Simmons turns 30 next year, and Barnwell notes that defensive tackles who struggle to play full 17-game seasons in their 20s rarely get more durable in their 30s.
• One big year. Before 2025’s 11 sacks, Simmonsaveraged just over six sacks per 17 games. Barnwell argues the Bears are paying for the best defensive tackle in football over the next three years when he has played at that level for a short stretch.
• Opportunity cost. Caleb Williams is on a rookie deal but is eligible for an extension after this season, and Barnwell expects it to be among the largest in NFL history. When a team pays its quarterback, he argues, cheap draft picks become more valuable, not less.
• The price. Using an assumed pick at No. 24 in each draft and a conservative draft-value model, he estimates the all-in cost at around $50 million per year, well above what Jalen Carter ($38 million) and Quinnen Williams ($35.3 million) got on their extensions.

That is Barnwell’s model, and the pick position is an assumption. The same ESPN package grades the trade as “probably overpaid” for Chicago.

The counterargument comes from Knox at Bleacher Report, who gave the Bears a B+. His key point is that the picks should land late. If Chicago keeps winning, they could be giving up less in traditional trade value than the Bengals paid for Dexter Lawrence (the No. 10 pick). Barnwell makes a similar point, noting the Bears’ offense is the cheapest in the league because Williams, Rome Odunze, Colston Loveland, Luther Burden III and others are all on rookie contracts. He also acknowledges Simmons would likely replace money the Bears were already planning to shed by moving on from Jarrett and Dayo Odeyingbo.

What Does This Do To The NFC Race?

ESPN Analytics now gives the Bears a 13% chance to win the NFC, second behind San Francisco (39%) and ahead of Seattle (11%). The 49ers and Seahawks both made moves on Tuesday, acquiring Buckner and guard Quenton Nelson from the Colts respectively. NFL framed the Simmons deal as Chicago leaping past both.

Chicago is 5-2 and faces the defending champion Seahawks on Monday night. Bleacher Report adds that the Bears are chasing an undefeated Minnesota Vikings team in the NFC North.

What’s Next For The Bears?

The shopping may not be finished. According to NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport, as relayed by Athlon Sports via Yahoo, Chicago still has a need on the edge. The name he floats is Khalil Mack, now 35 and on a one-year, $18 million deal with the winless Chargers (three sacks through six games). ESPN’s Fowler and Matt Bowen put his trade probability at 35%. Rapoport framed it conditionally: Mack becomes a top trade name if the Chargers don’t turn their season around. This is a rumor, not a done deal.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the Bears give up for Jeffery Simmons?

A 2027 first-round pick, a 2028 first-round pick and a 2027 fourth-round pick. They get a 2028 fifth-round pick back.

When did the trade happen?

Thursday, October 29, 2026.

Is Simmons under contract long-term?

Yes. He signed a three-year extension in June worth about $105.8 million, and reporting indicates it runs through 2030.

What is the NFL trade deadline?

November 10, 2026, at 4 p.m. ET.

Why is this trade historic?

Per ESPN Research, no defensive tackle had been traded for multiple first-round picks in the common draft era (since 1967).

The Bottom line

Chicago has bought certainty at a position of need with a quarterback still on a rookie contract. Tennessee has converted its most valuable asset into flexibility for a rebuild. The risk sits with the Bears. History says multi-first-round trades for veterans fail more often than they work, and Simmons turns 30 next year. The reward is a defense that finally has a player opposing offenses have to game-plan around in a season where the NFC looks open.

Sources & References

• ESPN: “Bears get Jeffery Simmons: Key intel on blockbuster trade”
• ESPN: “Jeffery Simmons traded to Bears: Does dealing multiple first-round picks work?
• NFL: “Bears acquire DT Jeffery Simmons from Titans in blockbuster trade”
• Bleacher Report: “Grading Jeffery Simmons Blockbuster NFL Trade Between Titans and Bears”
• Yahoo Sports (originally Athlon Sports): “Fresh Off Jeffery Simmons Blockbuster Acquisition, Bears Linked to Chargers’ Linebacker Deal, Says NFL Insider”